Rising Costs and Allegations of Fraud
As New York City grapples with record-breaking special education spending, allegations of fraud have surfaced, pointing to systemic issues within the reimbursement process for private schools. A lawsuit filed by Agudath Israel of America, an Orthodox Jewish advocacy group, has brought to light cases of alleged misconduct that city and state officials claim are inflating costs. Most of these cases involve yeshivas, religious schools serving the Hasidic community, and highlight concerns over taxpayer-funded special education services.
State education department filings revealed that reimbursement claims for private school special education services have skyrocketed, jumping from 7,600 claims in the 2018-19 school year to nearly 20,000 by 2022-23. Officials allege that some providers have exploited the system by billing for unnecessary or non-existent services. For instance, one provider sought $580 per hour for reading and math instruction, which a hearing officer deemed “excessive and unreasonable,” reducing the rate to $290. Other cases include forged contracts and fraudulent signatures, such as a provider charging over $32,000 for unrendered services.
These allegations have sparked heated debate, with the city’s education department citing the surge in reimbursement requests as a key factor in delays affecting students with disabilities. “These cases have overwhelmed our system,” said Liz Vladeck, general counsel for the department, who called for reforms to curb abuse and streamline services.
Community Pushback and Broader Implications
The lawsuit has drawn criticism from Agudath Israel, which denies that the Hasidic community is driving the rise in fraudulent claims. Avrohom Weinstock, the group’s chief of staff, condemned fraud but accused the city of deflecting blame for its long history of mismanaging special education. “This is about children,” Weinstock said. “We should be working together to find a workable solution for the children who need it.”
Special education services for private school students fall into two categories: families seeking tuition reimbursement for specialized programs unavailable in public schools and those relying on private providers for mandated services. It is the latter group, concentrated in Brooklyn neighborhoods with large Hasidic or Orthodox communities, that has seen a dramatic increase in claims. These cases made up two-thirds of the 26,000 filed last year, further straining the city’s overburdened system.
City officials, including Schools Chancellor David Banks, have linked ballooning costs to private school reimbursements, suggesting that funds intended for public school students are being diverted. Critics argue that the city should focus on directly providing services rather than litigating reimbursement claims, which cost a record $1.35 billion in 2022.
Reform Efforts and Legal Challenges
In response to mounting costs and fraud concerns, the city and state have introduced reforms aimed at improving accountability. Measures include setting “fair market” rates for services, requiring providers to be state-certified, and mandating family representatives at reimbursement hearings. However, Agudath Israel and families affected by the changes argue that these reforms have backfired, causing a collapse in the private provider market and leaving many students without necessary services.
The lawsuit contends that new rate caps are insufficient to cover costs, disproportionately affecting vulnerable students, including those from non-Hasidic backgrounds. “The NYCDOE could get costs under control by fixing its systemic violations and providing mandated services directly,” the suit argues.
As legal battles continue, the city faces pressure to balance fiscal responsibility with the needs of students requiring special education services. Stakeholders on all sides agree that the ultimate goal must be ensuring equitable access to education for every child, but disagreements over how to achieve that remain deeply entrenched.
Also Read: Minnesota Officials Subpoenaed in Feeding Our Future Fraud Investigation
